In 2020, Twitter user Aidan Moher invited his followers to share true stories about themselves that sounded too strange to be real. The thread quickly gained traction, with users flooding it with astonishing tales. One story, shared by Twitter user Amanda Nell Edgar, captivated readers with its sheer improbability.
During a date, Edgar joked about her clumsiness, only for the man to compare her to a woman who had suffered a freak accident and broken numerous bones. To her astonishment, Edgar realized he was unknowingly recounting her own story. “In college, I fell out of my bunk bed and broke both of my legs and one arm. Years later on a date, I made a joke about being clumsy, and the guy told me I couldn’t compare to this woman his EMT brother helped once… who fell out of her bunk and broke all the bones. It was me,” she recounted in a tweet.
A Clumsy Fall with Severe Consequences
Curious followers urged Edgar to share more details about the bizarre incident. She explained that she had fallen from a standard-height bunk bed, but the true culprit was a wooden desk chair positioned next to the bed. When she fell, her body landed on the chair, resulting in multiple broken bones. The tweet’s popularity surprised Edgar, prompting her to elaborate further in subsequent posts.
While her story was entertaining to readers, Edgar reflected on the challenging recovery process. She shared how her dorm and her parents’ house were not wheelchair accessible. “I ended up having to move back home and had to have someone wheel me to the bathroom on a desk chair (to fit through the door). Couldn’t wash my hair myself, friends came to help,” she said, highlighting the physical and emotional toll of the ordeal.
Unexpected Connections and Astonishing Discoveries
The thread revealed surprising parallels with other users’ experiences. One commenter, Glizzy McGuire, recounted breaking multiple bones from a similar fall, to which Edgar replied in amazement, “Wow! I, too, am shocked there are two of us!” Another Twitter user reminisced about seeing Edgar in their older sister’s yearbook as the girl who got her foot stuck in a hoop skirt during a school musical, forcing her to crawl offstage. Edgar confirmed the memory, saying, “Yes!!! I had forgotten all about this, but can confirm!”
When asked about potential medical causes for her injuries, Edgar disclosed that her severe fractures initially overshadowed any underlying concerns. However, years later, she discovered her vitamin D levels were critically low, a factor contributing to her fragile bones. Now, she takes prescription vitamin D supplements twice a week.
A Memorable Date with an Ironic Twist
Edgar’s story about the date gained widespread attention for its sheer irony. Her date’s attempt to one-up her with her own story left an unforgettable impression. Reflecting on the situation, she humorously agreed with another user’s observation, “Right! He was trying to [one-up] me with my own story.”
Despite the awkwardness of that particular encounter, Edgar later found the love of her life, though not with the man from that fateful date. Meanwhile, readers speculated that he would likely never forget the bizarre coincidence or his unwitting mistake.
From Clumsy Beginnings to Professional Success
Today, Edgar has moved far beyond the girl known for her bunk bed fall or stage mishap. She runs a successful ghostwriting business, “Page and Podium,” where she helps leaders craft compelling memoirs that enhance their personal brands. Her journey from a series of clumsy yet memorable moments to a thriving career serves as a testament to resilience and growth.
While Edgar’s experiences may have seemed outlandish at the time, they’ve ultimately shaped her into the accomplished individual she is today, inspiring others with her wit, humor, and remarkable story.
